Showing posts with label medieval. Show all posts
Showing posts with label medieval. Show all posts

Tuesday, July 12, 2022

Were Medieval European Swords Sharp?

Were Medieval European Swords Sharp?

Micro-research by Caleb Reynolds

One of the myths I have heard, since I was old enough to be interested in swords and all things medieval, was that European swords were not sharp in the middle ages. Only medieval, Asian swords were sharp. Captain Subtext steps in to tell us that medieval knights relied more on brute strength than on technique and good hardware. Sword "experts" claim, even today, that the technology to sharpen swords wasn't invented until the Renaissance and the birth of the rapier. One can go online and watch videos of non-experts claiming that the Japanese could sharpen a katana as sharp as a scalpel, but those ignorant Europeans just used "blunt crowbars". 

Why is this so? One can say, "Oh course, they sharpened swords. It wouldn't be a good sword if it wasn't sharp." One can also say, "They knew how to sharpen knives, sickles, and wood planes, why wouldn't they sharpen a sword?" Excellent points. But is there any evidence that they actually sharpened swords? Unfortunately, most surviving medieval swords have corroded over the centuries, destroying any indication of how sharp the original edge was. The court swords that have been well maintained, such as Britain's Curtana, were never intended to be used in combat and were never given a sharp edge that might hurt someone during a ritual or ceremony. 

We can infer that swords had to be sharp because people wore armor; we can see various types of armor to protect against thrusts, heavy strikes, and slicing attacks. Fighting manuals also mention cutting and slicing with one's sword. I.33, the world's oldest sword fighting handbook, uses the phrase, "and make a cut to the face" quite often when describing an attack/defense sequence. Surely, if the swords were blunt, there would be no reason to cut your opponent's face. I.33 also teaches us to use your buckler to protect your hand and arm from slicing attacks. A passage of "The Battle of Maldon" tells us that Byrhtnoth’s nephew, Wulfmær, was “slashed by the sword.” Not bludgeoned; slashed.  

Medieval battlefields give us plenty of examples of injuries that could only have come from sharp swords. The remains from the Battle of Visby (1361) show an extraordinary number of  lethal blows that clearly show that swords were sharp. The following image is from The death of a medieval Danish warrior. A case of bone trauma interpretation by Eva Forsom, Lene Warner, Thorup Boe, Bo Jaque, Lene Mollerup, published in Forensic Science. It shows a skull injury that was common among the remains excavated from Visby, a downward cut of the sword on the left-hand side of the skull; the sword sliced through the skin and bone. Notice how clean the edges are on the top edge of the cut: the sword clearly was sharp enough to cut through the bone.


There are plenty of similar examples of missing sections of skulls, as well as severed arms and legs. All with clean cuts indicating sharp weapons. But, do these injuries indicate wide-spread use of sharpened swords? What other evidence do we have? Particularly evidence that dates to the early medieval period. 

Let us start with The Anglo-Saxon Chronicle (finished around 1154): it gives the following text describing the The Battle of Brunanburh (937)

There lay many a warrior by javelins strewed,
Northern man over shield shot;
So the Scots eke, weary, war-sad.
West-Saxons onwards throughout the day,
In bands pursued the footsteps of the loathed nations.
They hewed the fugitives behind, amain, with swords mill-sharp.

So, by the 12th century, we have an English reference to not only sharp swords, but swords that were sharpened at a mill. Presumably a water-mill as wind-mills had yet to reach the British Isles by 1150. If a water mill was used to sharpen swords, then it most likely would have been set up to sharpen swords (and other weapons) in large quantiles. Possibly in conjunction with a sword smithery. 

What other evidence do we have?

Well, take a gander at this image from the Utrecht Psalter (Utrecht, Universiteitsbibliotheek, MS Bibl. Rhenotraiectinae, Nr 32) completed around the year 800.


Here we see, on the left, the Armies of the Wicked lining up against the Armies of the Righteous. Behind the wicked, on the left, you can see a wicked sword sharpener, sharpening a sword the "old fashion" way, with a horizontal whetstone. But, on the right-hand side, you can see two righteous sword sharpeners using the latest technology of the 9th century, the rotary grindstone. Here is a closer look.


Clearly a sword. Clearly being sharpened. 

Here this image was copied into the 12th century Eadwine Psalter:


Better illustrator and in color, no less. Here is a close up of the wicked sharpener from another psalter that was a copy of Utrecht:



He appears to be using a whetstone mounted on a stick. Perhaps for better leverage?

Here is an image from the 14th century MS. Bodl. 264, which shows two people either sharpening or polishing a sword. 


Here, from The Romance of Alexander, are two people using a grinding wheel.


And, here from the 14th century Luttrell Psalter. Although they appear to be sharpening a knife or a dagger. 



Here is another image of a knife sharpener, this time 15th century French:


And, here is a 16th century German woodcut depicting a man using a hand held whetstone to sharpen a sword. Possibly to remove a burr or to touch up a spot on the edge.

On top of all of the manuscript imagery I have shown, there were professional sword sharpeners: distinct from knife sharpeners. But, their wages and fees will have to wait for another time, or this micro-research paper will turn into a full-blown Ice Dragon Pent Paper.

I would like to close with a question: where did this idea of blunt swords come from? I think that it started with world famous non-historian, Sir Walter Scott Raeburn. Author of Ivanhoe, Rob Roy, The Lady of The Lake, The Bride of Lammermoor and Tales of the Crusaders. In his The Talisman, Sir Walter writes of a meeting between King Richard the Lionheart and Sultan Saladin (which never happened in real life). In the story, Richard and Saladin are comparing swords, as rich and powerful men are wont to do. Richard demonstrates his power by chopping a metal mace in two. Saladin, not to be outdone, pulled a silk veil from his turban tossed it into the air and sliced it in half with a flick of the wrist. This story, which, once again never happened in real life, has taken on a life of it's own, being repeated over and over until many people believe that it actually happened. Sir Walter's descriptive language, and the reputation he had as a historian, convinced generations that medieval European swords were blunt and only to be used for brute force and Asian swords, while small and dainty, were impossibly sharp. 

So. Could Richard have cut a solid metal mace, an "inch and a half" in diameter in twain with a single swing of a sword? Highly unlikely. Although, in the text, the metal was not named: it could have been gallium. Could Saladin have cut a silk veil in half as if floated through the air? Yes. I have seen modern sword masters do that with a variety of blade types. All it takes is a sharp edge and the skill to do it: Saladin would have had both. Richard could have done it with his sword; he certainly had the money for a really good sword and the training to know how to cut with it. 

I hope that this brief paper will inspire you, the reading, to pursue a deeper dive into this topic. There are so many rabbit holes to check out. Feel free to explore.

Friday, July 18, 2014

Generic procedure for re-creating any medieval cordial without distillation.

The following are "bullet" notes from a class I teach about medieval cordials. Since distillation of drinking alcohol is illegal in the USA, we have to fake the end product. The vast majority of cordials I've encountered, over the years, in A&S competitions and brewing roundtables, are vodka infusions based on modern recipes. We, as SCA brewers, can do better. I do understand the concept of "Creative Anachronism" but I believe that there is a huge difference between using modern equipment (stainless steel, digital thermometers) to make a medieval product and ignoring anything period, all together. I have heard from many brewers that they use modern ingredients and recipes because they taste better than period ones. That might be true, but it is hardly a method of producing and perfecting period beverages.

Here are my 10 points for faking any period cordial without distilling it yourself.


1) Use period recipes. While there are a plethora of modern cordial recipes, we are a historical organization and we should be attempting to produce a medieval product. There are plenty of period recipes to choose from, you just have to look. Curye on Inglysch, The Johnstone Manuscript, The Sloane Manuscript 521, L'Agriculture et Maison Rustique, Harleian Manuscript 2378, Delightes for Ladies, The English Housewife are all cookbooks, from 1615 and earlier, that contain cordial recipes.

2) Use good quality ingredients. Fresh is best. If the ingredients came out of your garden, then bonus points to you. If you have to use dried ingredients, then make sure that they are as young as possible. Don't use "el cheap-o" brand dried herbs or spices that you found in the back of a shelf in a store. There is a big difference between fresh, ground nutmeg and generic nutmeg powder.

3) Match your ingredients as best as possible. Make reasonable substitutions: spearmint for peppermint; California sage for French sage. White rose petals for red. Do not substitute an orange for an apple, or vodka for wine, or cilantro for parsley. I'm not talking about documenting various ingredients from multiple sources in order to create a new beverage; I am talking about taking a period recipe that calls for wine, cinnamon, sage and cloves and producing a beverage that is made with vodka, sugar, chilies and Frank's hot sauce (yes, I have seen this entered into an SCA A&S competition). Period chocolate cannot be substituted with Hershey's syrup. Vodka cannot be substituted for wine. Pork cannot be substituted for sturgeon. If you use a recipe that calls for strawberries, use modern strawberries if you cannot collect any wild ones, but note in your documentation that you made that change. Do not substitute blueberries.

4) If you cannot make your own wine, or have access to someone else's home made wine, use wine from the region the recipe is from. Use German wine for German recipes, French wine for French recipes, Spanish wines for Spanish recipes, Italian wine for Italian recipes and French wines for English recipes. No one had anything nice to say about English wine. If you wish to use "imported" wine, please take the time to demonstrate that the wine you used was found in the country where the cookbook was written. There is plenty of documentation showing that England and Scotland imported a lot of French wine. If your recipe calls for sherry, use Spanish sweet, or cream, Sherry.

5) Use un-aged, un-flavored "white" brandy to simulate your distilled wine. If you cannot find "white" brandy, use the least aged brandy you can find. As brandy ages, it will pick up some vanilla flavor from the oak in which it is stored. The longer it ages, the stronger the vanilla flavor becomes. Just document the added flavor.

6) If you are making a cordial based on distilled ale, or Usquebath (whiskey), I recommend using moonshine. Legal moonshine is readily available at lots of liquor stores and is closer to period whiskey than vodka. If you have a variety, pick one made without rye. Most moonshine I've seen in liquor stores are based on bourbon recipes, and can made from a blend of grains: barley, wheat, corn and rye. The rye gives a distinct flavor, so, if you have a choice, avoid it.

7) Make two beverages: the first you should follow the recipe up to distillation. This will be the "before" portion of your project. Then infuse the same ingredients into brandy (or moonshine) to simulate the post distillation liquid. Document that since you cannot distill, legally, you are producing the before and after products.

8) If you don't know what something is, don't use it. Cordials were medicine and recipes called for plants, herbs and spices to treat various medical issues. Most of these recipes assumed that the reader would know what a plant was and what part of it to use. One recipe from the Harleian Manuscript 2378 called for "red rose, germander (which some call capillus veneris), fennel, ivy, vervain, eyebright, endive and betony". I assume that one would use leaves and petals, but I could be wrong. Is the ivy mentioned the same as the ivy that grows near my house? According to a Google search, germander and capillus veneris are two completely different things: one is a plant and the other a fern. Which one do I use? I honestly do not know, so, I would use neither. One last point on this note: don't use things that are dangerous. Do not use poppy leaf juice. Do not add lead. Do not add anything that you might be allergic to. And please, if this is for a gift or an A&S competition, list the common names for everything you have used.

9) Only add sugar if your recipe calls for sugar. Sugar, in the SCA time period, was expensive. In 1464 1 pound of sugar cost 2s in London. The equivalent of 516 Pounds or $860 in today's money. By 1700 a pound of Sugar cost 7s a pound, in London, but the modern price dropped to around 28 pounds or about $46 in today's money. Use white sugar if the recipe calls for "candy sugar", otherwise use piloncillo, or Mexican unrefined, brown sugar.

10) Document everything you do and explain why you made any changes. It is not enough to say that you used fennel instead of sage: why did you make the substitution? It could be that you hate the smell of fennel. Or that you grabbed the wrong container. Or that you made it to use up excess sage. Document your reason. I have seen far too many pieces of documentation where a period recipe is listed, but the redaction lists items that don't appear in the original recipe. From a judge's perspective, it appears that either the brewer documented the wrong period recipe or that the brewer didn't care enough to do proper documentation. To return to our fennel/sage example. If you have a period cordial recipe that calls for fennel and another that calls for sage from the same source or time period, then you are all set; list both recipes. But, if you have a period cordial recipe that calls for fennel and you substitute a vanilla bean with no explanation as to why you made the switch and list not a single source about period vanilla, then you can expect poor marks in an A&S competition. Think of it this way: If you were documenting a period pie crust that called for lard and you used Crisco in its place, it is up to you to explain why. Now, you could document that while Crisco is not period, you keep a kosher house and cannot eat pork products. This is perfectly acceptable. But, if you use Crisco and don't explain why you didn't use lard, judges are going to call you on it.